Most of the companies whose shares are listed on global stock exchanges have recently reported their earnings results for the third quarter of 2018.

In this article we will discuss top commodity companies based on their current business results as well as take a further look into select commodity sectors, with the aim of finding out where in the cycle we currently are and what is the outlook for the future.

In the table below, we have prepared an overview of the fundamentally soundest companies which are in the business of mining key commodities i.e., gold, silver, copper and uranium.

Most of the companies from the above-mentioned list are currently included in our stock portfolio with the majority share being represented by gold and silver miners. *The market cap. data is in 000 USD.

miners 1Source: Proprietary analysis


With commodity markets still in deep correction, some of the best silver miners like Fortuna Silver (FSM), Silvercorp Metals (SVM) and Hecla Mining (HL) are trading below their book value (P/B).

Given that these are the companies with the lowest mining costs and highest profit margins we could say that commodity markets are acting quite irrationally. (it is safe to say there are a few short-term market anomalies)

During the course of the current correction SVM, FSM and HL have lost around 64% of their value. At the same time these are the companies that will most likely post above average gains when the trend reversal in commodity markets happens, similar to the price increase between January and August 2016.


According to the data of First Majestic (AG) for every ounce of gold mined, the mining industry mines 9 ounces of silver, which is completely disproportionate with the current price ratio as it takes as much as 85 ounces of silver to buy one ounce of gold.

There has been an annual shortage of about 500 million ounces on the silver market for the last 10 years. This may in turn result in supply shortage and consequently lead to parabolic growth of silver in relatively short term.

Part of the reason why the gold, silver and copper miners are at such low valuation levels right now is due to extremely high degree of short positions on the futures market, where there are no limits with regards to the amount big institutions can short.

Due to the fact that commodity markets are in a downturn there is even more of irrational speculative short selling of gold, silver and copper as speculators see an opportunity for a quick profit, therefore driving commodity prices even lower.

This type of extreme speculative short selling always results in trend reversal but it could take a few months and even lower prices before the reversal happens.


Copper miners deserve to be mentioned as well as they have lost about 40% of their value between January and October 2018.

We are currently trying to catch the bottom in copper market through our positions in Southern Copper (SCCO) and Freeport McMoran (FCX), with which we will try to catch the next big cyclical uptrend.

SCCO is a miner with the largest proven reserves of copper and the lowest mining costs in the world. On the other hand, FCX is production wise the biggest copper miner listed on a stock exchange.


Judging by the data provided by research and mining companies such as Wood Mackenzie in Teck Resources (TECK) it is currently forecasted that the copper production peak will be reached in 2020, resulting in a shortage that could be as big as 5 million metric tons annually by 2025.

It is worth mentioning, that it can take as much as 15 years from the discovery of the ore deposit till the mine is actually operative and can start supplying copper.

baker deficit


The uranium market represents probably the most asymmetric opportunity on the financial markets for the long-term investors. After the Fukushima nuclear disaster market started falling and reached its bottom in January 2016. There has since been a price consolidation with the market testing strong support level at 11,80$ for a few times.

The biggest uranium miners, including Cameco and Kazakhstani Kazatoprom have ceased about 20% of world production which is an equivalent of Saudi Arabia suspending their oil supply on the oil market.


Looking more in-depth at the uranium market, we have to point out a few factors that could play a role in the normalization of supply and demand on the market in the future:

  • Complete production stoppage of the two biggest uranium mines in the world McArthur River and Key Lake
  • Further reduction in uranium production by Kazakhstani state giant Kazatoprom
  • Launch of the new investment vehicle Yellow Cake, which recently bought for about 8 million pounds of uranium from Kazatoprom and has a 10 year contractual right for further purchases
  • Temporary uranium mine close Langer Heinrich owned by Paladin Energy
  • Closure of the Australian uranium mine Ranger till 2020
  • A ban on a Russian trade with the American nuclear power plants
  • Introduction of import tarifs on uranium by the US government
  • US government policy suspension of selling excess uranium
  • 57 new nuclear reactors under construction of which 19 in China
  • Gradual reopening of about 30 nuclear reactors in Japan after the Fukushima accident

We are currently maintaining a position of about 10% of our portfolio in the highest quality uranium miners and developers (CCJ, NXE, UUUU, URG, DNN in UEC).

proizvajalci urana portfelj

Commodity markets are currently on a relatively low price levels and if we assume that the new bull market started in January of 2016, we could conclude that there are 10 years of growth ahead of us. But with such growth there is always a possibility of price fluctuations of even 50% of individual commodity companies.

In the picture below we can see the cyclicality of commodities in relation to the US stock market index S&P 500 and it shows us that we are price wise still at the beginning of the bull market which started in January of 2016.

Commodities VS SP 500 eng

In the future, we will most likely regard the current correction of commodities as one of the best entry points for the exposure to the new commodity market bull run.

This publication is issued by CM-Equity AG (“CM-Equity”) and is for distribution in the Federal Republic of Germany only to professional investors who purchase or sell transferable securities for their own account or for the account of others in the context of their trade, profession or occupation. This publication is for the use of the addressees only. It may not be copied to or distributed to any other person in whole or in part without the written consent of CM-Equity. This publication is provided for general information purposes only and is furnished to you on a confidential basis. Any decisions to purchase any securities of the company must be made solely on the basis of the information contained in the official offering document relating to such securities and not on the contents hereof. The official offering document will be available at CM-Equity AG and the company. Any investment possibilities discussed in this publication may not be suitable for certain investors depending on their specific investment target or time horizon or in the context of their overall financial situation. It cannot be a substitute for obtaining independent advice. Please contact your bank’s investment advisor.

The distribution of this publication in certain jurisdictions may be restricted by law and persons into whose possession this publication comes should inform themselves about, and observe such restrictions. In the United Kingdom this publication or a copy of it is being distributed only to, and is directed at (a) persons who have professional experience in matters relating to investments falling within article 19(1) of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Financial Promotion) Order 2001 (the “Order”) or (b) high net worth entities falling within article 49(2) (A) to (D) of the order, and other persons to whom it may be lawfully be communicated, falling within article 49(1) of the Order (all such persons together referred to as “Relevant Persons”). Any person who is not a Relevant Person should not act or rely on this publication or any of its contents.

Neither this document nor any copy of it may be taken or transmitted into the United States or distributed, directly or indirectly, in the United States or to any U.S. person (within the meaning of regulations under the U.S. Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the Securities Act). The shares in the company have not been and will not be registered under the Securities Act and may not be offered or sold within the United States or to, or for the account or benefit of, U.S. persons, except pursuant to an exemption from, or in a transaction not subject to, the registration requirements of the Securities Act.

Neither this document nor any copy of it may be taken or transmitted into Japan, Australia, Canada, or distributed or redistributed in Japan, Australia, Canada or to any resident thereof. The distribution of this document in other jurisdiction may be restricted by law or persons into whose possession this document comes should inform themselves about, and observe any restrictions. Any failure to comply with these restrictions may constitute a violation of U.S., Japanese, Australian or Canadian securities laws or the laws of any other such jurisdiction. By accepting this document you agree to be bound by the foregoing restrictions.

This publication does not constitute a solicitation to buy or an offer to sell any securities and shall not be construed as constituting an offer to enter into a consulting agreement. Neither this publication nor any part of it establishes a basis for any agreement or other obligations of any kind. Neither CM-Equity, nor any syndicate member or other person acting in connection with the offering of any securities of the company or any other investment in securities of the company or any person connected

with any of them accepts any responsibility for liabilities arising from the publication and/or use of this publication or its contents. Neither CM-Equity nor any syndicate member guarantee the accuracy or completeness of information used for this publication and nothing in this publication shall be construed to be a representation of such a guarantee. Used information has not independently been verified. This document was made available to the company prior to its distribution or dissemination and changes were made thereafter. Accordingly, no representation or warranty, expressed or implied, is made as to the fairness, accuracy, completeness or correctness of the information and opinions contained in this report and no reliance should be placed on such information or opinions. Any opinions expressed reflect the current judgment of the analyst who prepared this publication in conjunction with his/her occupational activity and may be changed pursuant to future events and developments. Views expressed do not necessarily reflect the opinion of CM-Equity or any of the syndicated members. We reserve the right to change the views expressed in this publication at any time and without advance notice. CM-Equity may have issued other publications that are inconsistent with and reach different conclusions from the information presented in this publication. Those publications may reflect the different assumptions, views and analytical methods of the analysts who prepared them. Past performance should not be taken as an indication or guarantee for further performance, and no representation or warranty, expressed or implied, is made regarding future performance. This publication is being distributed by electronic and ordinary mail to professional investors, who are expected to make their own investment decisions without undue reliance on this publication.

Compulsory Information

CM-Equity AG is a Munich based company which is regulated under the laws of Germany and is subject to supervision of the Federal Financial Supervisory Authority, Marie-Curie-Straße 24-28, D-60439 Frankfurt.

Research Date:
Target price Conflict of interest (Key): 9

Specific disclosures according to Section. 34b para 1 no. 1 German Securities Trading Act and Ordinance on the Analysis of Financial Instruments.

Section 34b of the German Securities Trading Act in combination with the Ordinance on the Analysis of Financial Instruments requires a company preparing a securities analysis to point out potential conflicts of interest with respect to the analyzed company that is the subject of the analysis. A conflict of interest is presumed to exist, in particular, if a company preparing a security analysis

> holds a more than 5% interest in the capital stock of the analyzed company that is the subject of the analysis,

> has been a member of a syndicate that has underwritten the analyzed company’s securities in the previous 12 months,

> is serving as a liquidity provider for the analyzed company’s securities on the basis of an existing designated sponsorship contract,

> has been providing investment banking services for the analyzed company during the last 12 months for which a compensation has been or will be paid,

> is party to an agreement with the analyzed company that is the subject of the analysis relating to the production of the recommendation,

> or any of its affiliates are regularly trading securities issued by the analyzed company or securities based on these issues,

> or the analyst covering the issue has other significant financial interests with respect to the analyzed company that is the subject of this analysis, for example holding a seat on the company’s boards.

Key 1: The analyzed company actively provided information material for preparation of this publication.

Key 2: This publication has been customized to the analyzed company and has been modified afterwards before publication.

Key3a: The analyzed company owns more than 5% of the capital stock of CM-Equity and/or a company affiliated with CM-Equity.

Key3b: CM-Equity and/or a company affiliated with it and/or the analyst having prepared this publication owns more than 5% of the capital stock of the analyzed company.

Key 4: CM-Equity and/or a company affiliated with it serves as a liquidity provider for the analyzed company’s shares on the basis of an existing market maker or liquidity provider contract.

Key 5: CM-Equity acts as Lead Manager or Co-Lead Manager and/or Joint Bookrunner in an offering of shares of the issuer or has underwritten shares of the issuer within twelve months preceding publication.

Key 6: CM-Equity and/or a company affiliated with it and/or the author of this publication acquired shares of the analyzed company free of charge or for a consideration below the stated target price and before the shares’ public offering.

Key 7: CM-Equity and/or a company affiliated with it was subject to an agreement on services in connection with investment banking transactions with the analyzed company in the last 12 months or within the same period received consideration on basis of such an agreement.

Key 8: CM-Equity and/or a company affiliated with it receives commission earnings arising from commercial activities from the analyzed company.

Key 9: CM-Equity and/or a company affiliated with it is regularly trading securities issued by the analyzed company or one of its affiliates.

Key 10: A member of the managing board of CM-Equity and/or the author of this publication is member of the supervisory board of the analyzed company.

Key 11: This publication is a contract work for remuneration, initiated and paid by the analyzed company.

Key 12: This publication is a contract work for remuneration, initiated and paid by shareholders or backers of the analyzed company.

Key 13: CM-Equity and/or a company affiliated with it acts as a selling agent in the public offering of shares of the issuer.

Investment Recommendations (12 months investment period)

Buy: We expect a stock to rise by at least 20% and outperform the benchmark by over 10%.

Hold: We expect a stock to move within 10% of the benchmark.

Sell: We expect a stock to fall by at least 20% and underperform the benchmark.

The benchmark for the stocks analyzed in this publication is the DAX.

Statements according to Section 34b of the German Securities Trading Act and Ordinance on the Analysis of Financial Instruments

Sources of information

The information contained in this publication is derived from carefully selected public sources we believe are reasonable, particularly from providers of financial data, the issuers’ own publications as well as other public media.

Principles and methods of valuation

For the preparation of this publication CM-Equity has used methods of fundamental share analysis as well as quantitative/statistical methods and models (inter alia historical valuation approaches, asset-based evaluation methods or sum-of-the-parts methods, discount models or the economic profit approach, multiple-based models or peer-group comparisons). Valuation models are dependent on macroeconomic factors, such as exchange rates, interest rates, raw materials, and on assumptions about the economy. Furthermore, market sentiment and political developments affect the valuation of companies.

The valuation is also based on expectations that might change rapidly and without notice, depending on developments specific to individual industries. Consequently, our recommendations and price targets derived from the models might change accordingly. The investment ratings related to a 12-month period are subject to market conditions and can only represent a snapshot. The ratings might in fact be achieved more quickly or slowly than expected, or need to be revised upward or downward.

Analyst Declaration

The author’s remuneration has not been, and will not be connected with the investment recommendations or views expressed in this publication, neither directly nor indirectly.

Organizational provisions to avoid conflicts of interests

In order to prevent conflicts of interests CM-Equity has separated business units with access to confidential information (confidential units) from its research units by functional and/or special separation or by setting up access authorization for data. In particular, Investment banking units and units of other financial advisory as well as capital market activities are segregated by physical and non-physical boundaries from the research department of CM-Equity. This segregation of CM-Equity’s operative units as well as the transfer of the – often stock-exchange price relevant – information is controlled by a unit independent from trade-, corporate- and transaction units (compliance). This guarantees that the stock-exchange price relevant information is not being misused or being transferred illegally to units with access to publicly available information only.